Without getting too deep in the weeds, I think Scalia was wrong to accuse Posner of lying. At best there's a semantic dispute about what "doing legislative history" means. And it's very arguable that Scalia was doing legislative history in Heller even under his own definition.
And Posner responds.
ReplyDeleteWithout getting too deep in the weeds, I think Scalia was wrong to accuse Posner of lying. At best there's a semantic dispute about what "doing legislative history" means. And it's very arguable that Scalia was doing legislative history in Heller even under his own definition.