Thursday, January 24, 2013

Hitting another lawyer in the courthouse is a bad idea.

Various media outlets in West Virginia are reporting that one West Virgina attorney has been charged with malicious assault for allegedly beating up another West Virginia attorney in the Marion County Courthouse

Sometime between 2:30 and 3:00, on January 22, attorney Stephen Sean Murphy allegedly attacked attorney Scott Radman in the courthouse. Apparently waiting to get outside was not an option.  The two TV stations I linked to (WDTV and WBOY) both report that witnesses claim that Mr. Murphy continued to beat Mr. Radman on the head even after Mr. Radman lay helpless. 

You might think that allegations are a sign that Mr. Murphy was taking zealous advocacy in a case to a new level. But reports that the Marion County Sheriff's office does not know what started the fight and that it did not appear that the two attorneys were involved in a case together. Neither attorney has much of an online presence so it is unclear whether the attorneys even practice in the same area of law.

Mr. Radman was taken to the hospital. Mr. Murphy was arrested, arraigned, and released on a $10,000 bond. No word on whether West Virginia's office of Disciplinary Counsel will take action to investigate whether Mr. Muprhy's alleged conduct violates West Virginia's Rules of Professional Conduct. As a general matter one would like to think that a lawyer beating a helpless person about the head and face is frowned upon when it comes to maintaining and upholding the dignity of the profession.


  1. Sounds like Murphy has a "few screws loose". Any one else would be locked up for much less ! His mugshot never even appeared on the jail website ! Why the preferential treatment ? He sounds like a crazy thug to me !

  2. Per " Attorneys' courthouse fistfight leads to lawsuits " Radman was taken to Ruby Memorial Hospital with " two broken orbital (eye) sockets and a skull fracture" after that thug STEPHEN SEAN MURPHY beat him - how in the world is that man still practicing law ? Murphy should be in a jail cell !! Not practicing law ! What a menace to society !!


Comments on posts older than 30 days are moderated because almost all of those comments are spam.